| Year | Number One Song | Artist |
| 2023 |
Firm Foundation |
Cody Carnes |
| 2022 |
Me On Your Mind |
Matthew West |
| 2021 |
Good God Almighty |
Crowder |
| 2021 Cmas |
Little Drummer Boy (live) |
for King and Country |
| 2020 |
There Was Jesus (feat. Dolly Parton) |
Zach Williams |
| 2019 |
God Only Knows |
for King and Country |
| 2018 |
Reckless Love |
Cory Asbury |
| 2017 |
Glorious Day |
Passion feat Kristian Stanfill |
| 2016 |
Priceless |
For King and Country |
| 2015 |
Holy Spirit |
Francesca Battistelli |
| 2014 |
We Believe |
Newsboys |
| 2013 |
Overcomer |
Mandisa |
| 2012 |
Me Without You |
Toby Mac |
| 2011 |
Get Back Up |
Toby Mac |
| 2010 |
Children of God |
Third Day |
| 2009 |
There Will Be A Day |
Jeremy Camp |
| 2008 |
Call My Name |
Third Day |
| 2007 |
Something Beautiful |
Newsboys |
| 2006 |
Praise You In The Storm |
Casting Crowns |
| 2005 |
Strong Tower |
Kutless |
| 2004 |
Indescribable |
Chris Tomlin |
| 2003 |
He Reigns |
Newsboys |
| 2002 |
I Can Only Imagine |
Mercy Me |
| 2001 |
Song of Jabez |
According to John |
| 2000 |
God of Wonders |
Mac Powell & Caedmon's Call |
| 1999 |
Dive |
Steven Curtis Chapman |
| 1998 |
Into Jesus |
Dc Talk |
| 1997 |
Shout to the Lord |
Darlene Zschech |
| 1996 |
Breakfast |
Newsboys |
| 1995 |
Home Run |
Geoff Moore & the Distance |
| 1994 |
Heaven in the Real World |
Steven Curtis Chapman |
| 1993 |
Nothing's Gonna Keep Me From You |
Out of the Grey |
| 1992 |
I Need To Hear From You |
Petra |
| 1991 |
For The Sake of the Call |
Steven Curtis Chapman |
| 1990 |
Its Time |
The Winans |
| 1989 |
The River Will Flow |
White Heart |
| 1988 |
Awesome God |
Rich Mullins |
| 1987 |
God Loves A Broken Heart |
Jon Gibson |
| 1986 |
Celebrate |
Teri DeSario |
| 1985 |
Find A Way |
Amy Grant |
| 1984 |
Angels |
Amy Grant |